Skip to content

Articles

How to play (and beat) Guess the Footballer

What each of the six tiles tells you, which first guess to make, and a three-guess solve worked through tile by tile.

Guess the Footballer gives you eight guesses to find one mystery Premier League player. You don't get clues for free: every guess you make is compared with the answer, and the comparison is the clue. That makes your choice of guess the whole game. A good guess is not the player you think it is; it is the player whose tiles will tell you the most.

The six tiles

Each guess comes back as six tiles. Green means a match, yellow means close, grey means not close, and arrows on the number tiles point towards the answer.

  • Club. Green if your guess and the answer share any Premier League club, and the tile names it. If not, it is grey and shows your guess's main club, and every Premier League club your guess played for is ruled out (they collect under Not at in the What you know card). There is no yellow here. A question mark means a gap in our records stops us proving they never shared a club.
  • Nation. Green for the same nationality. Yellow for the same part of the world: England, Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland and Ireland count as one group, and every other nation goes by its confederation (the rest of Europe, Africa, South America and so on).
  • Position. Green if your guess plays in the same line: goalkeeper, defence, midfield or attack.
  • Born. Green for the same birth year, yellow within two years, with an arrow up if the answer was born later.
  • PL debut. The season of his first Premier League appearance. Green for the same season, yellow within two, with an arrow. A question mark means we can't be sure that season was really his first, so we don't compare it.
  • PL goals. Banded rather than exact: 0, 1–9, 10–24, 25–49, 50–99 and 100+. Green for the same band, yellow for the band next door, with an arrow. A question mark means one of the two goal totals isn't complete in our records, so it isn't compared.

Choosing an opening guess

The first guess is a probe. You want a player who sits in the middle of the ranges, so that every arrow tells you something. A forward born in the late 1970s or early 1980s who debuted around 2000 and played for a big club is a strong opener. Whatever comes back, the born and debut arrows halve the era, and the club tile has a decent chance of turning green.

Avoid opening with a cult hero from a small club. If the answer turns out to be a midfielder at Arsenal, a grey tile for a one-season striker at Barnsley tells you very little.

A worked example

Here is a solve worked through with the game's real rules. The answer is Michael Bridges, who isn't in the daily answer pool, so this spoils nothing.

Guess 1: Wayne Rooney

Tiles for Wayne Rooney
TileShowsMeans
ClubMan Utd, greyNo shared club: Manchester United and Everton are both ruled out
NationEngland, greenHe's English
PositionAttack, greenHe's a forward
Born1985, grey, arrow downBorn in 1982 or earlier
PL debut2002/03, grey, arrow downDebut in 1999/2000 or earlier
PL goals100+, grey, arrow downFewer than 50 Premier League goals

One guess has already done a lot. The answer is an English forward, born in 1982 or earlier, who made his Premier League debut by 1999/2000, scored fewer than 50 Premier League goals and never played for Manchester United or Everton. The toast says about a hundred players still fit, so the next guess should test a club while pinning down the dates.

Guess 2: Michael Owen

Tiles for Michael Owen
TileShowsMeans
ClubNewcastle, greenHe played for Newcastle United
NationEngland, greenConfirmed
PositionAttack, greenConfirmed
Born1979, yellow, arrow downBorn in 1977 or 1978
PL debut1996/97, greenDebut in 1996/97
PL goals100+, grey, arrow downStill fewer than 50

Put the two guesses together: an English striker born in 1977 or 1978, who made his Premier League debut in 1996/97, played for Newcastle at some point and scored fewer than 50 Premier League goals. Only one player in our records fits all of that, and the toast says so.

Guess 3: Michael Bridges

Six green tiles. Bridges broke through at Sunderland in 1996/97, scored 19 Premier League goals for Leeds in 1999/2000 and finished his Premier League days on loan at Newcastle. Solved in three, with five guesses spare and no hints used.

The key move was guess two. Owen was never going to be the answer, since Rooney's goals tile had already ruled out anyone on 50 or more. He was chosen because his birth year and debut sit right at the edge of the windows Rooney opened, and because he played for several clubs, so his club tile had a good chance of turning green.

Reading the tiles together

  • Combine the arrows. A grey arrow up from 1970 and a grey arrow down from 1979 means 1973 to 1976. Write the window down if it helps.
  • A grey club tile is information too. It rules out every Premier League club your guess played for, so a well-travelled guess clears a lot of ground. After three or four greys, the shortlist of possible clubs gets small.
  • Debut and birth year together give you a career shape. A player born in 1975 who debuted in 1993/94 broke through young. One born in 1975 who debuted in 2003/04 probably came to England late, which points you towards an overseas signing.
  • Yellow nation narrows hard. A yellow tile from a French guess means a European from outside the UK and Ireland; a yellow from a Scot means England, Wales, Northern Ireland or Ireland.
  • Watch the goal bands. Most defenders and goalkeepers sit in the 0 or 1–9 bands, so an answer in the 50–99 or 100+ band is almost always a midfielder or a forward.

When to use hints

There are three hints and they come in order. First, a Premier League club he played for that your guesses haven't already turned green. Second, four names to choose from: the three wrong ones also played for that club and fit your tiles as closely as possible, so you still have to think. Third, a fifty-fifty that strikes out two wrong names. Hints don't cost a guess, but a wrong pick from the names does, and hints show in your share. A sensible rule is to save the club hint for when you have a green nation and position but no club, and to keep the four names for your last two guesses.

If you enjoy working a player out from his record, Career Path does it from his clubs instead, and our Career Path guide works through an example. For a broader warm-up, Higher or Lower is good practice at knowing roughly how many goals a player scored.