Articles
Great escapes and points deductions: a history of Premier League relegation battles
Goal-difference drops, the 40-point myth, West Brom's Christmas escape and the deductions that rewrote the bottom of the table.
The title is usually settled by May. The bottom of the table is where the final day still matters, and where the Premier League's oddest numbers live. This is a short history of the relegation fight: the closest calls, the clubs that got out of trouble against the odds, and the points deductions that changed the bottom of the table.
How many points is enough?
Forty points is the figure every manager in trouble quotes. In 31 seasons of 38 games it has failed three times. Sunderland went down with 40 in 1996/97 and Bolton with 40 in 1997/98, and West Ham were relegated with 42 in 2002/03, the highest total ever to go down over 38 games. In the 42-game seasons it took more: Crystal Palace went down with 49 in 1992/93.
More often, the line is lower. West Brom stayed up with 34 points in 2004/05, the lowest total to survive without help from a deduction. Hull City (2008/09), West Ham (2009/10) and Aston Villa (2019/20) all survived on 35.
Down on goal difference
Five times the last relegation place has been decided between clubs level on points:
- 1992/93: Crystal Palace and Oldham both finished on 49. Oldham's goal difference was two better.
- 1995/96: Coventry, Southampton and Manchester City all finished on 38. City, with the worst goal difference of the three, went down.
- 1997/98: Everton and Bolton both had 40. Everton stayed up on goal difference.
- 2006/07: Wigan beat Sheffield United on the final day to finish level on 38 points and one goal better off.
- 2007/08: Fulham and Reading both had 36. Fulham's goal difference was three better.
The 2006/07 case had a sequel. West Ham, who finished above both clubs, had fielded Carlos Tevez that season under an ownership arrangement that broke league rules. They were fined rather than docked points, and Sheffield United's long legal fight over it ended in a settlement.
The great escapes
West Brom, [2004/05](/seasons/2004-05/). Bottom at Christmas, they went into the final day in last place with four clubs separated by two points: West Brom 34, Crystal Palace 33, Norwich 33 and Southampton 32 in the final table. West Brom won and the other three went down. No club had previously survived after being bottom on Christmas Day.
Leicester City, [2014/15](/seasons/2014-15/). Also bottom at Christmas, Leicester finished 14th on 41 points, six clear of the drop. Twelve months later they were champions.
Fulham, [2007/08](/seasons/2007-08/). Survival on goal difference, ahead of Reading, after a late run in Roy Hodgson's first months at the club.
Queens Park Rangers, [2011/12](/seasons/2011-12/). QPR lost at Manchester City on the final day, the match settled by Sergio Agüero's title-winning goal, and stayed up anyway because Bolton could only draw at Stoke. QPR finished on 37 points, one ahead of Bolton.
Points deductions
Four clubs have finished a Premier League season with points taken off. Two went down; two survived.
| Season | Club | Deducted | Final points | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1996/97 | Middlesbrough | 3 | 39 | 19th, relegated |
| 2009/10 | Portsmouth | 9 | 19 | 20th, relegated |
| 2023/24 | Everton | 8 | 40 | 15th, survived |
| 2023/24 | Nottingham Forest | 4 | 32 | 17th, survived |
Middlesbrough's is the deduction that decided a relegation. They lost three points for failing to fulfil a fixture at Blackburn in December 1996, and finished on 39. Without the deduction they would have had 42, one more than Coventry in 17th. The same season they reached both domestic cup finals and lost both.
Portsmouth became the first Premier League club to go into administration, in February 2010, and the nine-point penalty only confirmed a relegation that the results had already made likely. They reached the FA Cup final that May.
Everton and Nottingham Forest were both punished in 2023/24 for breaking the league's profit and sustainability rules. Everton's deductions eventually totalled eight points after an appeal reduced the first and a second case added more; Forest lost four. Both stayed up. Forest finished six points above Luton, who went down with 26.
The worst seasons
Derby County's 2007/08 is the benchmark for misery: one win, 11 points, 20 goals scored and 89 conceded. Southampton came closest to matching it in 2024/25 with two wins and 12 points. Sunderland have two of the lowest totals, 19 in 2002/03 and 15 in 2005/06, and Sheffield United's 104 goals conceded in 2023/24 is the most by any team over 38 games.
Who goes down most
Norwich City have been relegated from the Premier League six times, more than anyone else. Leicester, West Brom and Burnley have gone down five times each. Two Premier League champions have gone down after winning it: Blackburn Rovers, champions in 1994/95 and relegated four seasons later in 1998/99, and Leicester City, champions in 2015/16 and relegated in 2022/23.
For the clubs that only managed one season before going back down, see our piece on one-season clubs. And if you want to test how well you know the bottom three, Which Season? uses the relegated clubs as one of its clues.